10 Year Smoke Detector Comparision Chart

10 year smoke alarms have many benefits and are a good choice due to the fact that you never have to change the battery. In fact, according to a new law in California, all smoke alarms sold after the date July 1st’ 2015 need to be the 10 year types.

 Item NameTamper
First Alert P910 10-Year Maximum Protection Photoelectric Smoke and Fire Detector, WhiteNOPhotoelectricYES3V Lithium Ion Power Cell Included10 YEARS
First Alert PC910 10-Year 2 in 1 Photoelectric Smoke Detector with Carbon Monoxide Alarm, White
Carbon Monoxide
YESBuilt-In Lithium-Ion
X-Sense DS31 10-Year Lifetime Smoke Detector Fire Alarm with Photoelectric SensorNOPhotoelectricYESBuilt-In Lithium-Ion
Kidde i9010 10-Year Sealed Lithium Battery-Operated Smoke Alarm with Memory and Smart HushNOPhotoelectricYESBuilt-In Lithium-Ion
Brk Electronics Battery Tamper Proof Lithium Battery Operated, SA340BYESIonizationYESBuilt-In Lithium-Ion
First Alert 0827-SA340CN Sealed Smoke Alarm with 10 Year Lithium BatteryYESIonizationYESBuilt-In Lithium-Ion

When choosing a 10 year smoke detector, there are two types available, ionization and photoelectric. Ionization smoke alarms respond better to flaming fires while photoelectric sensors respond better to smoldering fires. A flaming fire can be described as a fast hot fire, like burning paper. A smoldering fires could be inside a wall, or like a cigarette in a mattress.

For best and complete protection, it is important that you use both. You can use individual ionization and photoelectric alarms or go for a dual sensor alarm. In the following sections we will go in to detail about each one.

How to choose a 10 year smoke alarm?

Ionization smoke alarms have traces of radioactive elements and they work by ionizing the air present inside the alarm using an electrical current. As smoke enters the ionization chamber, it disrupts the flow of current and triggers the alarm. Hence, these work better in cases of flaming fires.

Photoelectric smoke alarms on the other hand have a small light inside them and as smoke particles enter into the detection chamber, these diffract the light and this in turn triggers the alarm. This is the best choice when it comes to smoldering fires.

Dual sensor smoke alarms offer you both these technologies and hence are also the most expensive option. However, these are the best choices as far as protection from fire is concerned.

There is a fourth type of smoke alarm and that is the air sampling smoke alarm. The working of this alarm is similar to ionization alarms to some extent but these are more sensitive.

Batteries are the first thing that you should consider when choosing smoke alarms for your home or office. There are 9 V, AA, AAA and lithium batteries to choose from. Lithium batteries come with 10 year battery life and this is the most convenient option you have. All the others need to be replaced every one or two years. Hence, it is best to go for 10 year battery sealed smoke alarms. The size of your house and office is another factor that you need to consider. It is important that you install a smoke alarm in each and every room of your house including attic and basement. There should also be a smoke alarm in the hallway that leads to each of your bedroom. In the kitchens, you can go for photoelectric smoke alarms as ionization alarms may be triggered by cooking smoke. Also make sure that you look for the UL label. Underwriters Laboratories test smoke alarms and certifies them only when they meet the UL standards.

What are 10 year smoke alarms?

As the name suggests, these smoke detectors come with batteries those have a life of as many as 10 years. This means 10 year battery sealed smoke alarms come with 10 years of guarantee and that is what makes them the most popular choice in the market.

Benefits of 10 year smoke alarms

Convenience and security are probably the biggest benefits of using these smoke detectors. These have sealed life-long lithium batteries those last for 10 years. This means unlike the 9 V batteries those do not last for more than one or two years, these are not required to be replaced in a very short span of time.

Smoke alarms have been installed in more than 96 percent US homes and about 20 percent of those do not work due to dead or missing batteries. Also two-third of residential fire deaths occur in home those do not have smoke alarms or have non-functioning smoke alarms.

9 V and AA batteries as already mentioned do not last for more than 2 years and then they need to be replaced. This means you need to climb up the ladder, remove the alarm, replace the batteries, test the alarm and reinstall it. Most people would think ‘who requires this nonsense when they can go for the 10 year smoke alarms?”

All you need is a 10 year battery smoke alarm to solve this problem. These are powered by sealed life-ling lithium batteries and hence, there is not much fuss and hassles involved.

Features of 10 year smoke alarms

The basic feature of 10 year battery smoke detectors is the presence of life-long lithium batteries those need no replacement for 8-9 years. There are many companies those manufacture these alarms viz. Kidde, First Alert and a few others and it is completely up to you as which product you purchase.

If you are looking for something in budget, then you can go for Kidde fire alarms. There are both ionization and photoelectric 10 year smoke alarms that you can opt for. There are also 10 year smoke detectors those come with the dual ionization and photoelectric smoke detecting technology and it is best to go for these. Here are the basic features of 10 year smoke detectors:

• 10 year sealed lifelong lithium batteries
• Photoelectric or ionization smoke detecting technology. There are 10 years smoke alarms those come with both these technologies
• Test button to test if the alarm is working properly
• Tamper proof mechanism to prevent theft and unauthorized entry
• Hush button to silence nuisance alarm is present in most of them
• Low battery warning
• 10 year warranty
• Easy installation

These are some of the common features of 10 year smoke alarms but you there are ones those come with other features as well. it is best to consider these features before making the purchase so that you get one that suits your requirements.

Disadvantages of 10 year smoke alarms

There are not many disadvantages associated with these alarms. Most people who have used this claim that 10 year battery life is a myth and that the batteries need to be replaced after 8 or 9 years but that can be taken as an advantage only. After all, you do not need to replace them after a year or so.

Few people have said that they saw low battery warning after 3 years as well and there are many people who said that these alarms lasted for more than 15 years. Since many come with a 10 years warranty you can get it if something goes wrong before that.
National Fire Protection Association Recommendations

The National Fire Protection Association or the NFPA recommends that smoke alarms should be replaced every 10 years. Smokes alarms are subjected to failures randomly and it has been approximated that 30% of smoke alarms fail in a span of 10 years and this percentage rises to 50% in a span of 15 years. This is a risk that is not worth taking and hence, it is really important that you replace fire alarms every 10 years. Batteries should also be replaced as soon as you get the low battery signals.

Here’s What People Are Saying In 10 Year Smoke Alarm Reviews

10 year smoke alarms are immensely popular amongst people who make use of smoke detectors in their homes or offices. The customers love the fact that the batteries of these alarms last for many years and they do not have to worry about low battery signals one or two years after installing these. These are also easy to install and easy to use.However, there are few users who are not very happy with these smoke detectors as they saw the battery life ending in less than 2 years. To sum up, 10 year smoke alarms are a great choice if you are looking for performance and convenience. These come with warranties and hence, you can easily replace them if something goes wrong with the batteries or the interface.